Street Capitalist: Event Driven Value Investments

When I saw the 13F for Fairfax Financial Holdings (TSE:FFH) come out, one of the things I wondered was when Prem Watsa would do another acquisition. With Fairfax’s success over the last few years and good financial shape, I thought the company would be poised for an acquisition. Watsa has publicly said that they are not interested in straying too far out of the insurance business when it comes to acquisitions. They don’t want to build another Berkshire Hathaway.

So, I’m pretty happy to see this acquisition of Zenith National Insurance (NYSE:ZNT). Zenith is in the workers’ compensation insurance business, which means that policies are generally long tail, meaning that payouts happen over longer periods of time. To contrast, short-tail insurance usually has payouts over shorter periods of time and more frequently. This is typical when you look at the likelihood that a person will get into an accident in their car versus an injury at the workplace.

So why is acquiring long-tail insurance operations so beneficial to a company like Fairfax? For one, Zenith is well operated. Moreover, the long-tail policies enable Fairfax to increase the size of its float — which is the amount of Zenith receives in premiums that it does not have to be paid out immediately or held in reserves. That capital is often invested in securities, in Zenith’s case mostly bonds, which could potentially be redeployed into more attractive securities by smart capital allocators like the people at Fairfax. Fairfax is not the only smart investor to have acquired workers’ compensation insurance companies, Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway owns National Indemnity which has workers’ compensation operations in California.

The one stickler for the Zenith deal is the fact that Fairfax will have to issue a little equity to complete the deal but will still have about $1 billion in cash on hand after the acquisition.

Via Bloomberg:

Fairfax Financial Holdings Ltd., the Canadian insurer run by Prem Watsa, agreed to buy Zenith National Insurance Corp. for about $1.3 billion in cash, adding sales in California.

Fairfax will pay $38 a share, the Toronto-based company said today in a statement. That’s 31 percent more than Woodland Hills, California-based Zenith’s $28.91 closing price on the New York Stock Exchange yesterday. The deal is expected to be completed in the second quarter.

Watsa, 59, is betting on a rebound in a workers’ compensation market pressured by rising medical costs and falling payrolls. Like Warren Buffett at Berkshire Hathaway Inc. and Loews Corp.’s Tisch family, Watsa built his company by investing the assets of insurance operations, often in out-of- favor securities.

“Workers’ compensation is probably the softest of all lines right now,” Bob Hartwig, president of the Insurance Information Institute, said at a conference in November, using industry parlance for a market where rates are falling. “Rate accounts for the vast majority of premium reduction we have seen in workers’ compensation.”

…Zenith, run by Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Stanley Zax since 1978, said in its 2009 annual report that it has “a long-term record of outperforming the industry.” Zenith’s workers’ compensation loss ratio, a measure of how much of each dollar of premium is paid in claims, was lower than the industry average every year from 2002 to 2008, according to Zenith’s annual report.

“There will be no changes in Zenith’s strategic or operating philosophy,” Watsa said in the statement.

Watsa’s Fairfax Agrees to Buy Insurer Zenith for $1.3 Billion